Dishwash Detergent - Do We Really Need It
Dishwashing Detergent – Is It Really Necessary, or Will Hot Water Do the Same Job?
November 2026
Introduction
Have you ever washed your dishes in hot water without using dishwashing detergent and noticed that they still come out looking perfectly clean?
It's a reasonable observation and raises an interesting question: Is dishwashing detergent really necessary, or are we spending money on something that hot water can do just as well?
For generations, households and commercial kitchens have relied on dishwashing liquids to remove food residues, grease and bacteria from plates, glasses, cutlery and cooking utensils.
Yet hot water alone can remove a surprising amount of visible dirt, particularly when combined with scrubbing and rinsing.
So, does dishwashing detergent genuinely improve cleaning, or have we simply become accustomed to using it?
The answer lies in understanding the difference between removing visible food residues, removing grease and reducing microorganisms on food-contact surfaces.
In this article, we examine what hot water can achieve, how dishwashing detergents work, when detergent makes a meaningful difference and whether using less detergent could be a sensible way to reduce household and business cleaning costs.
Key Takeaways
-
Hot water alone can remove considerable amounts of loose food residue, particularly when combined with scrubbing.
-
Dishwashing detergent contains surfactants that help lift and remove grease, oils and other soils.
-
Dishes that look clean are not necessarily free from invisible grease or microorganisms.
-
Hot tap water is not normally hot enough to reliably sanitise dishes.
-
Using excessive detergent does not necessarily improve cleaning performance.
-
For routine handwashing, detergent, mechanical scrubbing and thorough rinsing provide a more reliable cleaning process.
-
Commercial kitchens and food businesses must follow applicable food safety and sanitising requirements.
Why Can Hot Water Alone Make Dishes Look Clean?
Hot water is an effective cleaning aid.
When plates, glasses and cutlery are exposed to hot water, several things happen.
Heat softens dried food residues, loosens some deposits and makes many fats and oils less viscous.
When combined with a brush, cloth or sponge, hot water can remove a substantial amount of visible contamination.
For example, a drinking glass used only for water may appear perfectly clean after being rinsed under a hot tap.
Similarly, a plate used for dry toast may require relatively little effort to remove visible crumbs.
This explains why washing dishes without detergent can sometimes appear to produce exactly the same result as washing them with detergent.
However, looking clean and being thoroughly cleaned are not necessarily the same thing.
A plate may appear spotless while retaining a thin film of oil or food residue that is difficult to see.
That is where detergent can make an important difference.
How Does Dishwashing Detergent Actually Work?
Dishwashing liquids contain cleaning ingredients known as surfactants.
Surfactants are molecules that help water interact with substances it would otherwise struggle to remove, particularly oils and grease.
One part of a surfactant molecule is attracted to water, while another part interacts with oily substances.
When detergent is added to water and the dishes are scrubbed, these molecules help loosen grease from the surface and disperse it into the wash water.
This makes oily residues easier to remove and helps prevent them from simply spreading around the dish or redepositing elsewhere.
Without detergent, hot water may soften grease, but some of that grease can remain attached to the surface or transfer to other items.
This is particularly noticeable when washing frying pans, roasting dishes, butter knives or plates used for oily foods.
The main purpose of dishwashing detergent is not simply to create bubbles. It is to improve the removal of grease and other food soils.
Does Hot Water Kill Bacteria?
This is one of the most misunderstood aspects of washing dishes.
Hot water can help remove food residues and microorganisms from surfaces, but the temperature of ordinary household hot water is generally insufficient to provide reliable heat sanitisation.
Many microorganisms can survive the temperatures commonly used for washing dishes by hand.
Effective heat sanitisation requires specific temperatures and contact times, which are normally achieved using appropriately designed commercial dishwashing equipment rather than ordinary handwashing.
Importantly, standard dishwashing liquid is generally a cleaner, not a disinfectant.
Its primary role is to help remove grease, food residues and microorganisms from surfaces through washing and rinsing.
It should not be assumed that ordinary dishwashing detergent kills bacteria unless the product specifically makes a substantiated antimicrobial claim.
For food safety, the objective is to use an appropriate cleaning process and, where required, a separate sanitising step.
Hot Water vs Dishwashing Detergent – What's the Difference?
| Cleaning Requirement | Hot Water Alone | Hot Water with Detergent |
|---|---|---|
| Loose food particles | Often effective | Effective |
| Dried food residues | Helps soften deposits | Helps soften and remove deposits |
| Light grease | May remove some | Generally more effective |
| Heavy grease and oils | Often less effective | Significantly improves removal |
| Invisible oily films | May remain | Better removal |
| Removal of microorganisms | Some removal through washing | Generally more reliable with proper scrubbing and rinsing |
| Reliable sanitisation | No, at normal handwashing temperatures | No, not with ordinary detergent alone |
| Everyday dishwashing | Variable results | More consistent results |
The key difference is consistency.
Hot water alone may work reasonably well on lightly soiled items, but detergent provides more dependable cleaning across a wider range of food residues.
Does More Dishwashing Detergent Mean Cleaner Dishes?
Not necessarily.
One of the most common mistakes when washing dishes is assuming that more detergent automatically produces better cleaning results.
Modern dishwashing liquids can be highly concentrated, and relatively small quantities may be sufficient for everyday washing.
Using excessive detergent can create unnecessary foam, increase rinsing requirements and result in avoidable product consumption.
The amount required depends on the detergent formulation, water volume, water hardness and level of soiling.
A lightly soiled collection of cups and glasses may require much less detergent than greasy frying pans and roasting trays.
Following the manufacturer's recommended dosage is generally the best starting point.
Effective cleaning depends on using the right amount of detergent, not simply the largest amount.
What About Washing Glasses and Cups?
Glasses and cups are particularly interesting because they often appear clean after rinsing with hot water.
A glass used only for drinking water may have very little visible contamination.
However, glasses can also contain residues from fingerprints, lipstick, milk, oils and other substances that water alone may not remove effectively.
Coffee cups may retain oils from coffee, while cups used for milk-based drinks can develop residues containing fats and proteins.
These deposits are often more effectively removed using detergent.
For hospitality businesses, consistently clean glassware and crockery are particularly important for presentation, customer satisfaction and food safety.
Can Dishwashing Detergent Save Water and Energy?
Although detergent is an additional product cost, it may also make washing more efficient.
When grease and oils are difficult to remove, people often compensate by using hotter water, scrubbing for longer or repeatedly rinsing items.
Detergent can help remove these residues more readily, potentially reducing the amount of water and effort required.
However, actual savings depend on washing habits, detergent dosage and the types of dishes being cleaned.
For example, leaving a hot tap running continuously can waste considerably more water and energy than washing dishes in a suitably filled sink or basin.
Using the correct amount of detergent, avoiding unnecessary water use and washing efficiently can provide a sensible balance between cleaning performance and operating costs.
Is Dishwashing Detergent Necessary in Commercial Kitchens?
Commercial kitchens, cafés, restaurants and other food businesses have additional responsibilities when it comes to cleaning food-contact surfaces.
Removing visible food residues is only part of the process.
Food businesses must ensure that utensils, equipment and food-contact surfaces are cleaned appropriately and sanitised where required under their food safety procedures.
For manual dishwashing, this commonly involves removing food scraps, washing with a suitable detergent, rinsing where required and applying an appropriate sanitising method.
Commercial dishwashers may use controlled wash and rinse temperatures or approved chemical sanitising systems.
Simply rinsing commercial kitchen equipment in hot water should not be regarded as a substitute for an established cleaning and sanitising procedure.
In New Zealand, food businesses should follow their applicable Food Control Plan or National Programme requirements and relevant Ministry for Primary Industries guidance.
Expert Tips – Getting Better Results from Dishwashing Detergent
1. Use the Correct Dosage
Follow the detergent manufacturer's instructions rather than automatically adding large amounts.
2. Remove Food Scraps First
Scraping plates and utensils before washing reduces contamination of the wash water and improves cleaning efficiency.
3. Use Warm or Hot Water Where Appropriate
Warm water can improve grease removal, but excessively hot water increases scalding risks and may waste energy.
4. Wash Lightly Soiled Items First
Start with glasses and cups, followed by plates and cutlery, leaving heavily greased cookware until later.
5. Replace Dirty Wash Water
When wash water becomes heavily contaminated with grease or food residues, replace it rather than continuing to wash in dirty water.
6. Rinse Thoroughly
Follow the detergent manufacturer's rinsing instructions to remove loosened food soils and detergent residues.
7. Allow Dishes to Dry Hygienically
Air drying on a clean rack can help avoid recontamination from repeatedly used tea towels.
Common Dishwashing Mistakes to Avoid
-
Assuming dishes are hygienically clean simply because they look clean.
-
Using excessive detergent in the belief that more foam means better cleaning.
-
Relying on normal hot tap water to sanitise dishes.
-
Continuing to wash in heavily contaminated water.
-
Using dirty sponges, brushes or dishcloths.
-
Leaving detergent residues on food-contact surfaces.
-
Treating ordinary dishwashing detergent as a disinfectant without checking its intended use.
Dishwashing Efficiency Checklist
Before washing dishes, consider the following:
-
Have food scraps been removed?
-
Is the water at a suitable, safe temperature?
-
Am I using the recommended detergent quantity?
-
Are my brushes, sponges and cloths clean?
-
Am I replacing dirty wash water when necessary?
-
Have dishes been rinsed as required?
-
Are dishes being dried and stored hygienically?
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I wash dishes using only hot water?
Hot water can remove some food residues, particularly from lightly soiled items. However, it is generally less effective than detergent for removing grease, oils and certain invisible residues.
If my dishes look clean, doesn't that mean they are clean?
Not necessarily. Some oily residues and microorganisms cannot be seen. A dish can appear spotless without having been thoroughly cleaned.
Does dishwashing detergent kill bacteria?
Ordinary dishwashing detergent primarily helps remove soils and microorganisms through washing and rinsing. It should not be assumed to disinfect unless the product has an appropriate antimicrobial claim.
Is hot water more important than detergent?
Both play different roles. Hot water can soften and loosen residues, while detergent improves the removal of grease and oils. Mechanical scrubbing and thorough rinsing are also important.
Is expensive dishwashing detergent better than cheaper detergent?
Not automatically. Cleaning performance depends on formulation, concentration, dosage and the type of soil being removed. A more expensive detergent may be economical if less product is required per wash.
Can I reduce the amount of dishwashing detergent I use?
Possibly. If you are currently using more than the recommended amount, reducing the dosage may save money without compromising cleaning performance.
Conclusion – Is Dishwashing Detergent a Waste of Money?
The simple answer is no, but using more than you need certainly can be.
Hot water is capable of removing a surprising amount of visible food residue, which explains why dishes can appear perfectly clean without detergent.
However, hot water alone is generally less reliable at removing grease, oils and invisible residues.
Dishwashing detergent performs a specific function that water cannot always achieve effectively on its own.
The sensible approach is not necessarily to use more detergent, but to use the correct amount for the job.
For households, this can mean reducing unnecessary product consumption while maintaining effective cleaning.
For commercial kitchens and hospitality businesses, using suitable detergents as part of an established cleaning and sanitising process remains particularly important.
Ultimately, the goal is not to use the most detergent or the hottest water. It is to achieve consistently clean dishes with the least practical amount of product, water, energy and effort.
Looking for Dishwashing Detergents and Kitchen Cleaning Products?
Hawke's Bay Packaging & Cleaning Solutions (HBPCS) supplies a range of dishwashing detergents, commercial kitchen cleaning chemicals and hygiene products for households, hospitality businesses and commercial facilities.
Choosing the right product and using it at the recommended dilution can help improve cleaning efficiency while managing operating costs.
Visit www.hbpcs.co.nz to explore our dishwashing and kitchen cleaning range, or contact our team for product advice.
Article Information
Published: November 2026
Category: Dishwashing & Kitchen Hygiene
Reading Time: Approximately 8 minutes
Disclaimer
This article provides general educational information about dishwashing detergents and cleaning practices. Cleaning performance depends on the detergent formulation, water conditions, equipment, food residues and washing method. Ordinary dishwashing detergent should not be assumed to sanitise or disinfect surfaces. Commercial food businesses should follow their applicable food safety requirements, product instructions and approved cleaning and sanitising procedures. Always refer to manufacturer instructions and relevant New Zealand food safety guidance.